The Apologetics
History of the Bible

66 books, one story

The Old Testament was written across more than a thousand years; the New Testament, within about one lifetime. This page walks through when scholars believe each book was actually written and by whom, including the places where traditional and mainstream critical scholarship genuinely disagree, shown side by side rather than picked for you.

TraditionalEvangelical / classical datingCriticalMainstream critical scholarship

Where a book shows only one view, traditional and critical scholarship are in broad agreement. For how these dates are actually determined (manuscript comparison, internal textual evidence, external corroboration), see Sources & Method.

Each book's card below links to the specific manuscripts behind its dates, with images from the museums and research libraries that hold them.

Old Testament

39 books · c. 1446–430 BC

The Torah (Pentateuch)

Genesis through Deuteronomy. Traditionally treated as a single Mosaic corpus; critical scholarship treats it as a composite built from several source strands over centuries.

Manuscript evidence2

Qumran copies of the Torah: About 240 biblical scrolls have been recovered from the Qumran caves, and the five books of the Torah are among the most copied of all: roughly 30 copies of Deuteronomy, 20 of Genesis, and 17 of Exodus survive, either whole or in fragments.
Nash Papyrus: A small scrap containing the Ten Commandments and the Shema, copied in the 2nd century BC. It predates the Qumran discoveries and was, before 1947, the oldest known Hebrew Bible manuscript of any kind.

Genesis

Read
TraditionalMosesc. 1446–1400 BC
CriticalComposite (J, E, P sources)c. 950–450 BC

Narrates events traditionally placed far earlier (the patriarchs, c. 2000–1800 BC); the composition date is distinct from the events it describes.

Exodus

Read
TraditionalMosesc. 1446–1400 BC
CriticalComposite (J, E, P sources)c. 950–450 BC

Some evangelical scholars favor a later 13th-century BC date for the Exodus event itself; both early- and late-date camps hold to Mosaic authorship.

Leviticus

Read
TraditionalMosesc. 1446–1400 BC
Critical"P" (Priestly) sourcec. 600–450 BC

Numbers

Read
TraditionalMosesc. 1446–1406 BC
CriticalComposite (mainly "P")c. 600–450 BC

Deuteronomy

Read
TraditionalMosesc. 1406 BC
Critical"D" sourcec. 700–550 BC

Critical scholarship commonly links the core of "D" to the law scroll discovered during Josiah's temple repairs (2 Kings 22, c. 622 BC).

⚑c. 400 BCTorah recognized as authoritativeThe first section of the Hebrew Bible to be treated as closed and authoritative.

Historical Books

Joshua through Esther. Joshua–Kings is widely treated by critical scholars as a single "Deuteronomistic History" compiled during the exile from older sources; Chronicles–Esther are post-exilic on both traditional and critical reckonings.

Manuscript evidence1

The gap at Esther: Fragments of every Old Testament book except Esther have turned up at Qumran. No one knows for certain why; it may simply be an accident of preservation, or it may reflect Esther's famously late and contested entry into the canon.

Joshua

Read
TraditionalJoshua (with later additions)c. 1400–1370 BC
CriticalDeuteronomistic historian(s)c. 620–550 BC

Judges

Read
TraditionalUnknown (Jewish tradition: Samuel)c. 1050–1000 BC
CriticalDeuteronomistic historian(s)c. 620–550 BC

Ruth

Read
TraditionalUnknown (Jewish tradition: Samuel)c. 1000–950 BC
CriticalAnonymousc. 500–400 BC

Many critical scholars tie its date to the post-exilic debate over foreign marriage reflected in Ezra–Nehemiah.

1 Samuel

Read
TraditionalUnknown (partly Samuel per tradition)c. 1000–900 BC
CriticalDeuteronomistic historian(s)c. 620–550 BC

2 Samuel

Read
TraditionalUnknownc. 970–900 BC
CriticalDeuteronomistic historian(s)c. 620–550 BC

1 Kings

Read
TraditionalUnknown (Jewish tradition: Jeremiah)c. 850–800 BC
CriticalDeuteronomistic historian(s)c. 560–550 BC

2 Kings

Read
TraditionalUnknown (Jewish tradition: Jeremiah)c. 560–550 BC

Narrates Jehoiachin's release from Babylonian prison (c. 562 BC) as its final event, so both traditional and critical scholarship place its final form shortly after the exile began, one of the few historical books where the two views converge.

1 Chronicles

Read
TraditionalEzra (Jewish tradition)c. 450–400 BC
CriticalAnonymous "Chronicler"c. 400–250 BC

2 Chronicles

Read
TraditionalEzra (Jewish tradition)c. 450–400 BC
CriticalAnonymous "Chronicler"c. 400–250 BC

Ezra

Read
TraditionalEzrac. 440–400 BC
CriticalEzrac. 400–350 BC

Largely agreed to be post-exilic on both views; the debate is mainly over exact decade, not century.

Nehemiah

Read
TraditionalNehemiah (memoir)c. 430–400 BC
CriticalNehemiah (memoir)c. 400–350 BC

Esther

Read
TraditionalUnknown (Jewish tradition: Mordecai)c. 460–400 BC
CriticalAnonymousc. 300–150 BC

Notably absent from the Dead Sea Scrolls, which some scholars take as evidence of a later or more contested place in the canon.

Wisdom & Poetry

Job through Song of Songs. Traditional authorship (Solomon, David) reflects ancient Near Eastern convention of ascribing wisdom literature to a renowned royal patron; critical scholarship weighs linguistic evidence more heavily.

Manuscript evidence1

Psalms: the most-copied book at Qumran: Around 36 separate Psalms manuscripts have been identified among the scrolls, more than any other Hebrew Bible book, including the large Great Psalms Scroll (11QPsa) recovered from Cave 11.

Job

Read
TraditionalUnknown (traditions vary: Moses, or a contemporary of Job)Patriarchal era–monarchy (wide range)
CriticalAnonymousc. 600–400 BC

One of the most genuinely unresolved dates in the Hebrew Bible. The narrative setting is ancient, but little in the text anchors the composition date on either view.

Psalms

Read
TraditionalMultiple (David, Asaph, sons of Korah, Solomon, Moses, others)c. 1400–450 BC, compiled by c. 400 BC
CriticalMultiple (David, Asaph, sons of Korah, Solomon, Moses, others)c. 1000–300 BC, compiled by c. 300 BC

The overall span of composition is broadly agreed; the real divergence is how reliable the individual authorship superscripts (e.g. "of David") are taken to be.

Proverbs

Read
TraditionalSolomon (core), with later additionsc. 970–700 BC
CriticalSolomon (core), with later additionsc. 900–400 BC

Ecclesiastes

Read
TraditionalSolomonc. 940–930 BC
CriticalAnonymous, writing in Solomon's voicec. 450–180 BC

The Hebrew's late linguistic features lead most scholars, including a significant number of evangelicals, to treat "Solomon" as a literary persona rather than the literal author.

Song of Songs

Read
TraditionalSolomonc. 970–930 BC
CriticalSolomonc. 400–200 BC
⚑c. AD 100Writings substantially settledThe third section (Psalms, Job, Proverbs, and the rest) reaches broad consensus; debate over a handful of books (e.g. Esther, Song of Songs) continues into the 2nd century AD.

Major Prophets

Isaiah through Daniel. Isaiah and Daniel are the two classic test cases for authorship division in Old Testament scholarship; Jeremiah and Ezekiel are comparatively uncontested.

Manuscript evidence1

Great Isaiah Scroll (1QIsaa): A nearly complete copy of Isaiah copied c. 150–100 BC, the oldest and most complete biblical manuscript ever found, and close enough to the medieval Masoretic Text to confirm careful transmission across a thousand-year gap. About 21 separate copies of Isaiah survive from Qumran altogether. The Israel Museum has digitized the whole scroll, column by column, with a full English translation alongside it.

Isaiah

Read
TraditionalIsaiah ben Amoz (single author, all 66 chapters)c. 740–680 BC
CriticalFirst Isaiah (1–39), Second/Deutero-Isaiah (40–55), Third/Trito-Isaiah (56–66)c. 740–500 BC, across three authors

The majority critical view since the 19th century: chapters 40–55 address the Babylonian exile and name Cyrus as a contemporary liberator, which most scholars read as writing from within the exile rather than predicting it centuries in advance.

Jeremiah

Read
TraditionalJeremiah (with his scribe Baruch)c. 627–580 BC
CriticalJeremiah (with his scribe Baruch)c. 627–550 BC

Authorship is comparatively uncontested; the live scholarly debate is textual. The Greek (Septuagint) version is about one-eighth shorter than the Hebrew, and scholars disagree over which reflects an earlier edition.

Lamentations

Read
TraditionalJeremiahc. 586–570 BC

The book is anonymous within its own text; the attribution to Jeremiah is a later tradition, though the date (shortly after Jerusalem's fall) is not seriously disputed.

Ezekiel

Read
TraditionalEzekielc. 593–571 BC

One of the least disputed prophetic books. The text's own internal dating formulas are unusually precise and consistent, and both traditional and critical scholarship accept them.

Daniel

Read
TraditionalDaniel, a Judean exile in Babylonc. 605–536 BC
CriticalAnonymous, writing under Daniel's namec. 167–164 BC

The majority critical position: chapter 11's detailed accuracy through the Hellenistic period, followed by a sharp shift to vague predictions right around 164 BC, is read as history written after the fact rather than long-range prophecy.

Minor Prophets

Hosea through Malachi. Most are dated with reasonable confidence from internal historical references; Jonah and Joel are the clearest cases of traditional/critical divergence.

Manuscript evidence2

The Minor Prophets as one scroll: The twelve Minor Prophets regularly circulated as a single continuous scroll rather than as separate books. The Wadi Murabba'at Minor Prophets scroll (MurXII, c. AD 115) preserves the whole collection in order, and several more partial copies turned up at Qumran.
Pesher Habakkuk: A first-century BC commentary quoting Habakkuk 1–2 verse by verse before interpreting each one. One of the best-known Qumran documents, and an early witness to Habakkuk's text in its own right.

Joel

Read
TraditionalJoelc. 830–800 BC (one proposal)
CriticalJoelc. 500–400 BC (the more widely held proposal)

Genuinely unresolved on both traditional and critical scholarship. The book gives almost no historical anchors, and the post-exilic date is now held by many evangelical scholars too, not only critical ones.

Obadiah

Read
TraditionalObadiahc. 586–550 BC

A minority of scholars propose a 9th-century BC setting instead, tied to an earlier fall of Jerusalem to raiders.

Jonah

Read
TraditionalJonahc. 780–750 BC
CriticalAnonymous, writing of Jonahc. 450–350 BC

The majority critical view treats the book as a later didactic narrative about the historical 8th-century prophet mentioned in 2 Kings 14:25, rather than his own writing.

Haggai

Read
TraditionalHaggai520 BC

Internally dated with unusual precision to the second year of the Persian king Darius I.

Zechariah

Read
TraditionalZechariah (all 14 chapters)c. 520–480 BC
CriticalZechariah (chs. 1–8); anonymous "Deutero-Zechariah" (chs. 9–14)c. 520–300 BC, across two authors

A division similar in kind, if smaller in scale, to the Isaiah debate: chapters 9–14 differ in style and lack the precise dating formulas of chapters 1–8.

Malachi

Read
TraditionalAnonymous or pseudonymous ("Malachi" may mean "my messenger")c. 460–430 BC
⚑c. 200 BCProphets recognized as authoritativeThe second section (the Former and Latter Prophets) gains recognized status.

New Testament

27 books · c. AD 48–95

Gospels & Acts

All four Gospels are formally anonymous within their own text; the traditional author names (Matthew, Mark, Luke, John) come from external church tradition, first clearly attested in the early-to-mid 2nd century.

Manuscript evidence4

Rylands Papyrus 𝔓52 (fragment of John 18): The earliest surviving New Testament manuscript fragment of any kind, usually dated c. AD 100–150 on handwriting comparison, though Brent Nongbri's peer-reviewed re-examination argues the method's real margin of error is wider than often presented, and a late 2nd- or early 3rd-century date can't be ruled out.
Papyrus 45 (Chester Beatty Gospels & Acts): Copied c. AD 250, P45 originally held all four Gospels and Acts in a single codex; substantial portions survive of Mark, Matthew, Luke, and Acts.
Bodmer Papyri 𝔓66 and 𝔓75: P66 (c. AD 200) preserves most of John, and P75 (c. AD 200) preserves substantial portions of Luke and John, both well over a century before the great codices.
Over 2,000 manuscripts, and counting: Taken together, the Gospels survive in over 2,000 Greek manuscripts, not counting lectionaries, by far the largest category of New Testament text.

Mark

Read
TraditionalJohn Mark (companion of Peter)c. AD 55–65
CriticalJohn Mark (companion of Peter)c. AD 65–75

Widely agreed to be the earliest Gospel; the main debate is whether it was written shortly before or shortly after Jerusalem's destruction in AD 70.

Matthew

Read
TraditionalMatthew the apostle (former tax collector)c. AD 50–70
CriticalAnonymous Jewish-Christian authorc. AD 80–90

The majority critical view holds the author used Mark and a hypothesized sayings collection ("Q") as sources, too late for the eyewitness apostle, in that reading.

Luke

Read
TraditionalLuke (physician, companion of Paul)c. AD 60–80
CriticalLuke (physician, companion of Paul)c. AD 80–95

Even many critical scholars find the traditional identification with Luke the physician plausible; the main dispute is date, not author.

John

Read
TraditionalJohn the apostle, son of Zebedeec. AD 85–100
CriticalA "Johannine community" or school, over timec. AD 90–100

Dates are close on both views; the real divergence is whether one apostolic eyewitness wrote it or a community shaped it across multiple stages.

Pauline Epistles

Scholars across the spectrum sort Paul's letters into tiers: undisputed (near-universal agreement), and disputed/"deutero-Pauline" (a real, documented split). The Pastoral Epistles (1–2 Timothy, Titus) are the most contested of all.

Manuscript evidence1

Papyrus 46: the earliest edition of Paul's letters: Copied c. AD 200, P46 preserves nine of Paul's letters bound together in a single codex (Romans through 1 Thessalonians, plus Hebrews), and is the earliest substantial manuscript of the Pauline corpus. It's split today between the Chester Beatty Library in Dublin and the University of Michigan.

Romans

Read
TraditionalPaulc. AD 57

One of the most securely dated books in the New Testament on any view.

Galatians

Read
TraditionalPaulc. AD 48–55

Authorship is undisputed; the date range reflects a geographic question (which "Galatian" churches it addresses) rather than an authorship debate.

Ephesians

Read
TraditionalPaulc. AD 60–62
CriticalA later follower, writing in Paul's namec. AD 80–100

A genuinely split question. Many critical scholars still defend Pauline authorship.

Philippians

Read
TraditionalPaulc. AD 60–62

Among the least disputed of Paul's letters written from imprisonment.

Colossians

Read
TraditionalPaulc. AD 60–62
CriticalA close associate, shortly after Paul's deathc. AD 70–80

A substantial minority of critical scholars still defend Pauline authorship here.

1 Thessalonians

Read
TraditionalPaulc. AD 50–51

Likely the earliest surviving Christian document of any kind, predating even the Gospel of Mark.

2 Thessalonians

Read
TraditionalPaulc. AD 51–52
CriticalA later imitator, correcting over-realized eschatologyc. AD 80–100

1 Timothy

Read
TraditionalPaulc. AD 62–64
CriticalA later follower, writing in Paul's namec. AD 90–110

One of the three "Pastoral Epistles," the most widely doubted group in the Pauline corpus, though serious evangelical scholarship (e.g. Marshall & Towner) still defends authenticity.

2 Timothy

Read
TraditionalPaulc. AD 64–67
CriticalA later follower, writing in Paul's namec. AD 90–110

Traditionally regarded as Paul's final letter, written shortly before his death.

Titus

Read
TraditionalPaulc. AD 62–64
CriticalA later follower, writing in Paul's namec. AD 90–110

Philemon

Read
TraditionalPaulc. AD 60–62

One of the least disputed Pauline letters, a short, personal note with little theological material to contest.

General Epistles & Revelation

Hebrews through Revelation. Several of these books are anonymous even in the earliest manuscripts, so "traditional author" here often means the earliest guess rather than an internal claim.

Manuscript evidence3

Papyrus 72 (1–2 Peter and Jude): A 3rd- to 4th-century codex among the Bodmer Papyri, preserving 1 Peter, 2 Peter, and Jude alongside several early Christian hymns and homilies.
Papyrus 74 (Acts and the General Epistles): A 7th-century Bodmer codex covering Acts, James, 1–2 Peter, 1–3 John, and Jude, later than most papyri but a direct witness to this whole corpus in one book.
Papyrus 47 (Revelation): A 3rd-century Chester Beatty papyrus covering the middle third of Revelation, roughly chapters 9 through 17. Revelation survives in fewer manuscripts overall than any other New Testament book, reflecting its later and more contested place on some early canon lists.

Hebrews

Read
TraditionalUnknown (early guesses: Paul, Barnabas, Apollos, Priscilla)c. AD 60–69
CriticalUnknown (early guesses: Paul, Barnabas, Apollos, Priscilla)c. AD 60–95

The text never names its own author, and both traditional and critical scholarship agree the question is likely unrecoverable, a case of shared uncertainty, not division.

James

Read
TraditionalJames, brother of Jesusc. AD 45–62
CriticalAnonymous, writing in James's namec. AD 80–100

If genuine, among the very earliest New Testament writings, since James was martyred in AD 62.

1 Peter

Read
TraditionalPeter the apostlec. AD 60–65
CriticalA later author, possibly using Peter's namec. AD 70–90

The polished Greek style, unexpected from a Galilean fisherman, is the main point critical scholars raise; the letter itself names a secretary, Silvanus (5:12), as a possible bridge.

2 Peter

Read
TraditionalPeter the apostlec. AD 65–68
CriticalAnonymous, writing in Peter's namec. AD 100–150

Widely regarded, by a strong majority of scholars across the theological spectrum, not only critical ones, as the New Testament's strongest candidate for pseudonymous authorship, and possibly its latest-written book.

1 John

Read
TraditionalJohn the apostlec. AD 90–95
CriticalJohn the apostlec. AD 90–100

Dates are close on both views; the real question is whether the apostle personally wrote it or a Johannine community did.

Jude

Read
TraditionalJude, brother of Jesus and Jamesc. AD 65–80
CriticalJude, brother of Jesus and Jamesc. AD 90–100

Some scholars date it later given its apparent use by 2 Peter, and doubt the direct family attribution.

Revelation

Read
TraditionalJohn the apostle (or "John of Patmos")c. AD 95

AD 95, under Domitian, is the majority date on both traditional and critical scholarship, following the early testimony of Irenaeus. A significant minority on both sides argue for c. AD 68–69 under Nero instead, based on internal clues like the "sixth king" of chapter 17, making this one of the few NT dating disputes that doesn't split neatly along traditional/critical lines.

⚑AD 367Earliest list matching all 27 booksAthanasius's 39th Festal Letter is the earliest surviving document to list exactly the 27 books of the modern New Testament, with no more and no fewer.
⚑AD 393–397Councils of Hippo & CarthageRegional North African councils affirm the same 27-book list, reflecting consensus rather than creating it.
View full bibliography →31 sources cited on this page